Mariah Carey’s Christmas Princesses
Ever since the world collectively decided to coronate Mariah Carey as the Queen of Christmas, as usual with women in pop culture, the talk of which hopeful Christmas Princesses could replace her almost immediately followed. However, she’s only grown in her festive ferocity over the decade since embracing her Christmas royal status.
This year marks the 30th anniversary of her Queen-making song, “All I Want For Christmas is You,” and it’s clear that Carey’s Christmas confection has inspired many of her musical daughters to follow in her stiletto steps. In their sonic choices, lyrical themes, or festive holiday promotional campaigns, all of pop’s princesses want a piece of Carey’s Christmas monarchy. While she won’t be relinquishing the throne any time this century, she has blessed a few of these Christmas princesses with her coveted stamp of approval.
In this playlist, I’m ranking Carey’s Christmas princesses holistically based on several factors: the quality of their original songs, how genuine and committed they are to the genre, their cultural impact, and their reverence for the Queen.
12. Sabrina Carpenter, “Santa doesn’t know you like I do”
Fresh off of a breakout year as pop’s latest it-girl, Sabrina Carpenter wasted no time entering the Christmas conversation. In the Best New Artist nominee‘s Christmas variety special on Netflix, “A Nonsense Christmas,” she repackaged her 2023 holiday EP, “fruitcake,” for mass consumption. As sassy and sexy as her latest hits, the set is heavy on humorous innuendo that would make even the sweet-as-“Honey” Queen of Christmas Mariah Carey blush. However, on “santa doesn’t know you like i do” Carpenter tones down the innuendo in favor of cutesy Christmas tidings that make it perfect for holiday playlisting.
11. Katy Perry, “Cozy Little Christmas”
Always good for a throwback, this 2010s hitmaker released her first and only Christmas song, “Cozy Little Christmas,” in 2018. Perry put her pop songwriting sensibilities to good use for this bubbly bop that gives a modern twist to the classic Christmas uptempo sound. While there is nothing particularly fresh about its plodding piano and sleigh bell-adorned production, that’s what makes it so, well… cozy. Considering how tritely unremarkable her latest album was, she might want to go full-throwback and consider a Christmas album.
10. Ava Max, “1 Wish.”
Ava Max made her second Christmas contribution this year with the release of “1 Wish,” a supercharged pop confection that is as catchy as it is cheerful. Wholly wholesome, she opts to celebrate the Christmas season by rattling off as many items on her list of must-haves to say that her “1 Wish” is for every day to be like Christmas. Refreshingly, it is not another rewrite of the “All I Want For Christmas is You” theme in different words. Ava Max could certainly deliver a solid Christmas album one day, perhaps that’s her fans’ “1 Wish.”
9. Leona Lewis, “One More Sleep”
Since her debut as the British X-Factor winner, Leona Lewis has been compared to Mariah Carey due to her immense vocal talent and style. Like Carey, Lewis recorded a Christmas album as her fourth set in 2013. Unlike Carey, her career peaked there. Regardless, “One More Sleep” has endured over the decade-plus since its release as a minor but beloved bop inside and outside her fanbase. She reissued the album in 2021 and toured the UK for Christmas in 2023, slowly and wisely nurturing a Christmas legacy.
8. Tamar Braxton, “No Gift”
Tamar Braxton might have a very famous sibling, but she’s a self-proclaimed Lamb. She’s always shown reverence for the Queen. You can hear the influence all over her work. So, it’s no wonder that Braxton would go on to record a Christmas album… and that it’s heavily Mariah-spired. “No Gift” has the same theme as Carey’s quintessential classic, but is on the opposite end of the sonic spectrum. Braxton serves drama on this slow-building ballad that works in several classic Christmas piano interpolations.
7. Jennifer Hudson, “Santa For Someone”
In 2020, Jennifer Hudson joined the Queen of Christmas on a special “Oh Santa!” remix alongside Ariana Grande for Carey’s Apple TV+ Christmas special. In 2023, the trio had a surprise reunion at Carey’s Madison Square Garden Christmas show. Hudson released her first Christmas album this season, “The Gift of Love.” On one of its original tracks, “Santa For Someone,” Hudson masterfully executes a high-energy, horn-driven groove that’s as bombastic as it is festive. While her non-holiday music hasn’t made much of an impact, she stands a chance to make quite the name for herself in the genre. The Queen of tributes, Hudson at covering songs and making them her own. With a successful daytime talk show and Carey’s co-sign, in time, she’ll find her way.
6. Kelly Rowland, “Love You More at Christmas Time”
Kelly Rowland began her Christmas story in 2000 when Destiny’s Child recorded their first-ever Christmas song for a Rosie O’Donnell Christmas album. For you post-Millennial generation folks, I can’t even explain that for you right now. But it was a thing. Anyway, the trio released a full-length Christmas set the following year, on which Rowland had a solo cover of “Do You Hear What I Hear” heavily inspired by Whitney Houston’s rendition.
Through the years Rowland has continued to flirt with her festive side, recording several more Christmas tracks, the highlight of which is “Love You More at Christmas Time.” This original was recorded for her first Lifetime Christmas film, “Merry Liddle Christmas.” The film went on to have two sequels. With “Love You More at Christmas Time,” Rowland, like Carey, masters the pop crossover sound while maintaining her R&B sensibilities for the upbeat, romantic track. It’s been over a decade since Rowland’s last full-length album, and once she finally follows that up, it’d be nice if she recorded a solo Christmas album one day.
5. Ariana Grande, “Santa Tell Me”
In true Lamb fashion, Ariana Grande wasted no time releasing Christmas music. In 2013 and 2015, she dropped Christmas EPs; in 2014, she released her biggest holiday hit: “Santa Tell Me.” The sweet sing-a-long checks all the boxes that we’ve come to expect from a modern pop Christmas carol – thanks to Ms. Carey. Year after year, “Santa Tell Me” has become more popular, partly due to Grande’s own growing popularity, and just the simple fact that Christmas songs thrive on nostalgia. Her Christmas profile has also been aided by popular duets with the Queen of Christmas (on “Oh Santa!”) and Kelly Clarkson.
Still, it’s been 10 years since “Santa Tell Me” dropped, and nearly that for “Christmas & Chill.” While Grande’s artistry has grown over the years, her Christmas music is stuck in her less interesting musical past. With her improved vocal skills and matured sound, she could be higher on this list if she released a full-length Christmas set now– one that’s a little more Broadway and a little less “chill.”
4. Tori Kelly, “25th”
Severely underrated songstress Tori Kelly took advantage of all that pandemic free time and dropped one of her generation’s best Christmas albums. She worked closely with R&B legend Babyface to produce the album, and it does not disappoint. Kelly was even nominated for the Best Traditional Pop Vocal Album GRAMMY for the set. While all three of her original tracks are quite good, “25th” is the album’s shiniest, stickiest moment. It combines all the expected, Christmasy, sonic elements – a horn section, cheerful piano, jingling sleigh bells, a saxophone solo – with cutesy but not too cliched lyrics and a sing-a-long melody that’re ready for caroling. Of course, then there’s those signature Tori Kelly vocal acrobatics.
Another thematic daughter of Carey’s “All I Want,” Kelly manages to pull it off without it sounding reductive. Similarly, she’s also done the only commendable cover of Carey’s classic – an acoustic rendition that was included as a bonus track on the deluxe edition of A Tori Kelly Christmas – as a tribute to Carey according to a 2020 interview. Only a top tier heiress could pull of that challenge.
3. JoJo, “December Baby”
The second December Baby on our list, Joanna “JoJo” Levesque lands just above her Sagitarrius sister Tori Kelly because when it comes to Christmas, JoJo has been down. Her first foray into the festive season was in 2004 – months after her debut album dropped, she performed at the annual Christmas in Washington special. Throughout the years, she’s done several live and recorded covers. She even recorded a masterful cover of Carey’s “Miss You Most (At Christmas Time)” in 2018, to “pay homage to the QUEEN Mariah Carey. Imagine being so dope that you single handedly own an entire holiday season!!!?! Her voice and writing has enchanted and inspired me since I was a little girl.” JoJo’s faithful rendition was emotive and expertly executed.
In 2020, like Tori Kelly, she dropped her first full-length Christmas album, “December Baby.” Of the original tracks, the title track is the most upbeat and festive, a younger, more groovy sibling of “All I Want.” Though another original, “Wishlist” with PJ Morton, is actually the superior song – and a sibling to “Miss You Most” – I wanted to keep this playlist on the happier side. The infectious “December Baby” is an excellent entry into the Christmas canon that’ll have you grooving all December long.
2. Kelly Clarkson, “Christmas Eve”
Of all of the Princesses on this list, nobody is working harder or more actively to secure her place as Christmas royalty than Kelly Clarkson. Having released two Christmas albums and entered the top 10 of the Billboard Hot 100 this week with her first original, “Underneath the Tree,” Clarkson has made a name for herself in the holiday genre. While that song is her most well-known and fits the cookie-cutter mold of what’s expected of an uptempo, pop Christmas song, my favorite Clarkson uptempo original is “Christmas Eve.”
Originally released as a standalone single in 2017, “Christmas Eve” ditches the romantic trope, popularized by “All I Want” and later emulated in Clarkson’s own “Underneath the Tree,” and instead celebrates the holiday itself. Clarkson delivers it superbly, lyrically, vocally, and production-wise. It’s high-energy and festive to the max. Penned by Clarkson and her musical director Jason Halbert, it shows that she has a knack writing for this sort of song. The only thing keeping Clarkson from the top of my list is that it does feel like she’s going almost too hard to earn her crown, rather than let it gracefully come to her. I respect the hustle, but nostalgia takes time. In the case of “Underneath the Tree,” it had a ten-year crawl to the top 10. It’s too bad that song is too cookie-cutter to be truly magical.
1. Britney Spears, “My Only Wish (This Year)”
On the polar opposite end of the spectrum is the Princess of Pop, Britney Spears, who reigns this list. My favorite Christmas original, out of all the songs by all of Mariah’s daughters, is her only holiday offering: “My Only Wish (This Year).” Unlike Clarkson, Spears has ignored the song’s existence since its release in 2000. There are no live performances, no music videos, and Spears doesn’t do anything to promote it during the holidays. In 2020, her label issued a vinyl single, and it was featured in the 2021 Netflix film, “Single All the Way.”
Released in 2000, just six years after Carey’s “All I Want,” it is perhaps the first to emulate its stylistic sensibilities. Perhaps being the first is why it’s also done the best. It’s Britney at her peak: pop perfection. She also delivers one of her best, most genuine vocal performances. Overall, what makes the song so good is that it’s so innocent. She was a young, new, but hugely successful star hungry to give her all to every song she sang. At the same time, she wasn’t trying to lay down the next Christmas classic, land a hit single, or become the Queen of Christmas. That expectation wasn’t there in 2000. She just had a damn good time, and made a damn good song. Just like Mariah Carey did in 1994, with “All I Want for Christmas is You.” But Britney if you hear me… it’s time to claim your crown.